should you help balthazar bg3

Table of Contents

1. The Architect of the Absolute: Who is Balthazar?
2. The Nature of the Request: A Deal with a Devil
3. The Case for Assistance: Pragmatism and Power
4. The Case Against: Moral Corruption and Strategic Folly
5. The Weight of Consequences: Ketheric Thorm and Beyond
6. A Matter of Role and Principle: Defining Your Own Path

The question of whether to help Balthazar in Baldur's Gate 3 is not a simple binary choice between right and wrong. It is a complex moral and strategic dilemma that cuts to the heart of the game's themes of power, corruption, and free will. Balthazar, the necromancer serving General Ketheric Thorm, presents players with a pivotal request that forces them to examine their priorities, their ethics, and their ultimate goals. The decision to aid him or defy him is one of the most significant role-playing moments in Act Two, with profound implications for the narrative and the player's character.

Balthazar is not a mere minion; he is the chief architect of Ketheric Thorm's immortality and the military might of the Absolute's forces in the Shadow-Cursed Lands. As a master necromancer, he resides in the depths of the Gauntlet of Shar, surrounded by his grim creations and dedicated to a singular, blasphemous purpose. His work is the linchpin of Thorm's invulnerability, involving the manipulation of a relic of immense power and the soul of Thorm's daughter, Isobel. Understanding Balthazar's role is crucial. Helping him is not assisting a minor functionary but directly empowering the primary enemy's central command structure. His cold, clinical demeanor masks a fanatical devotion to his craft and his master, making him a uniquely dangerous and influential figure.

His request is deceptively straightforward: retrieve the Nightsong, a mystical being held in the Shadowfell, for his experiments. He presents this as a transactional necessity, a step towards defeating Ketheric Thorm. However, the subtext is thick with menace. The Nightsong is no mere object but a living, immortal Aasimar named Dame Aylin. Balthazar's intention is to use her essence to perfect his control over death itself, further entrenching Thorm's power. Agreeing to help means becoming an accomplice in a profound act of desecration. The "deal" offers a temporary alliance of convenience but demands the surrender of a pure soul to a fate worse than death. It is a classic pact with a devil, offering a shortcut at an unthinkable cost.

There are pragmatic arguments for assisting Balthazar. From a purely survivalist viewpoint, his offer provides a clear, if grim, path through the Gauntlet of Shar and directly to Ketheric Thorm's inner sanctum. He provides a Sending Stone that bypasses significant obstacles, saving time and resources. For characters aligned with power at any cost, such as those embracing the Dark Urge or seeking the Absolute's strength for themselves, Balthazar represents a valuable teacher and ally. The knowledge he possesses about necromancy and the Netherstones is immense. Furthermore, temporarily aligning with him can be seen as a strategic manipulation, using the enemy's resources before a planned betrayal. The power he can unlock, both in terms of narrative progression and potential gameplay rewards, is a tangible temptation for the morally flexible.

Conversely, the moral and strategic arguments against helping Balthazar are compelling. On an ethical level, consigning Dame Aylin to eternal torment is an act of profound evil. It betrays the trust of allies like the Harper Jaheira and the cleric Isobel, who seek to free the Nightsong. It aligns the player character with the very forces of death and shadow they are presumably fighting against. Strategically, empowering Balthazar is ultimately self-defeating. Successfully delivering the Nightsong to him does not weaken Ketheric Thorm; it completes the ritual that makes him truly unstoppable, leading to a far more difficult confrontation. It strengthens the enemy's greatest asset. Choosing to defy Balthazar, to free the Nightsong, not only is the morally righteous path but also the tactically sound one, as it directly undermines the source of Thorm's invincibility and gains a powerful celestial ally in Dame Aylin.

The consequences of this choice ripple through the rest of the game. Helping Balthazar culminates in a fierce battle against Dame Aylin herself within the Shadowfell, forcing you to destroy a symbol of hope to satisfy the necromancer's greed. This path leads to a fortified Ketheric Thorm, a betrayed Isobel, and the loss of potential allies. Defying Balthazar triggers a thrilling battle against the necromancer in his foul laboratory, a fight for the very soul of the Nightsong. Victory here fractures Thorm's power base, sets Aylin free, and galvanizes the forces of resistance. The aftermath defines the tone of your journey into Act Three, coloring your relationships and the challenges you will face.

Ultimately, the question of whether you should help Balthazar is a defining moment for your character. It is a litmus test for your role-playing principles. Are you a pragmatist willing to walk through moral shadows to reach a goal? Are you a power-hungry individual who sees a useful tool in the necromancer's dark arts? Or are you a hero who draws a line, recognizing that some shortcuts cost too much and that true strength lies in resisting corruption, even when it is presented as a practical solution? Baldur's Gate 3 does not provide a correct answer, only consequences. The choice to help Balthazar or to resist him is where you move from being a passenger in the story to its author, writing your own tale of sacrifice, ambition, or redemption with every decision.

Doubled U.S. steel, aluminum tariffs spark criticism, trade war concerns across globe
Over 3,000 Boeing workers on strike "for fair contract"
Gaza ceasefire after weekend violence allows humanitarian aid in again: UN
S. Korean president calls for advancing multilateral cooperation within APEC
No explosives found on Air India flight after emergency landing in Thailand: airport