should i go with hadvar or ralof

Should I Go With Hadvar or Ralof? The Definitive Choice at Helgen

Table of Contents

Introduction: The Crossroads of Fate

Chapter 1: The Imperial Perspective - Following Hadvar

Chapter 2: The Stormcloak Path - Siding With Ralof

Chapter 3: Practical Consequences - Loot, Gear, and Early Gameplay

Chapter 4: Role-Playing and Narrative Alignment

Chapter 5: The Long-Term View - Impact on the Civil War

Conclusion: A Choice That Defines Your Dragonborn

Introduction: The Crossroads of Fate

The opening moments of Skyrim present a choice that feels monumental, even if its immediate practical effects are subtle. As the dragon Alduin attacks the execution site at Helgen, the player, bound and nameless, must scramble to safety through the keep. The decision manifests in a split-second: follow the Imperial soldier, Hadvar, or the Stormcloak rebel, Ralof. This is not merely a selection of an escort through a tutorial dungeon; it is the first meaningful role-playing decision of the game, setting a tone for the Dragonborn's journey. It asks a foundational question about allegiance, perspective, and the kind of hero you intend to become. While the game's vast world eventually opens beyond this initial fork, the path taken in Helgen carries distinct practical, narrative, and symbolic weight.

Chapter 1: The Imperial Perspective - Following Hadvar

Choosing Hadvar aligns you, however temporarily, with the authority of the Empire. Hadvar is a career soldier, weary of the conflict but duty-bound. His dialogue reveals a man who sees the Stormcloaks as misguided rebels prolonging a war that weakens Skyrim for the true threat: the Aldmeri Dominion. By following him, you witness the chaos from the Imperial side. His uncle, Alvor, in Riverwood, offers a sympathetic view of the Empire's plight, speaking of heavy taxes and the White-Gold Concordat as bitter but necessary pills to swallow for survival. From a purely practical standpoint in the keep, Hadvar will encourage you to loot gear from Imperial soldiers. This provides a steady, if standardized, supply of early armor and weapons. His path also leads to a subtle but lasting benefit: when you later report to the Imperial camp near Riverwood, the blacksmith, Gerdur, will not be available for trade if you followed Ralof, but Hadvar's presence ensures all Riverwood merchants remain accessible immediately. This choice frames the Stormcloaks as the instigators of the immediate trouble, casting Ulfric's rebellion as a destabilizing force at a time when unity is needed.

Chapter 2: The Stormcloak Path - Siding With Ralof

Ralof represents the passionate, nationalist fervor of the Stormcloak Rebellion. His defiance in the face of execution is palpable. Choosing him is an act of solidarity with the Nord struggle for independence and the right to worship Talos freely. His narrative in the keep is one of righteous resistance against an oppressive, foreign-controlled Empire. He speaks of Skyrim's stolen glory and Ulfric's rightful claim to the throne. Loot in this path comes from fallen Stormcloak soldiers, offering the same tier of gear but from a different factional source. In Riverwood, it is Ralof's sister, Gerdur, who provides sanctuary. Her home becomes your safe haven, and she voices strong support for the Stormcloak cause, giving you a ground-level view of the rebellion's popular support. This path immerses you in the grievance of the Nords, making the Empire's actions feel like a cruel occupation. It frames the initial conflict as a fight for freedom, making the Imperial legionaries seem like brutal enforcers of an unjust decree.

Chapter 3: Practical Consequences - Loot, Gear, and Early Gameplay

The immediate gameplay differences between the two paths are nuanced but noteworthy. The primary divergence lies in the source of your initial equipment and the availability of certain NPCs. Following Hadvar allows you to loot Imperial gear and, crucially, gain early access to a full set of heavy Imperial armor from a chest he points out. Following Ralof yields Stormcloak gear and easier access to a set of hide armor early on. The most cited practical difference involves the Riverwood blacksmith. If you follow Ralof, the Imperial-aligned blacksmith, Alvor, may initially be hostile or unavailable for trade until you complete the Bleak Falls Barrow quest for the Jarl of Whiterun, which resets faction dispositions. Hadvar's path avoids this minor inconvenience. Furthermore, the choice influences which soldiers you fight in the keep—Imperials if with Ralof, Stormcloaks if with Hadvar—offering slightly different combat experiences and loot tables. However, these are early-game considerations; within a few hours, players will outgrow this starter gear, and merchant access normalizes.

Chapter 4: Role-Playing and Narrative Alignment

Beyond loot, the choice's true power lies in narrative framing and role-playing consistency. A character conceived as a loyal Nord, deeply devoted to Talos and skeptical of Imperial authority, finds a natural beginning with Ralof. His path validates the character's inherent biases and provides an emotional entry point into the Civil War questline. Conversely, a pragmatic character, an outsider, or someone who values continental stability and fears the Aldmeri Dominion would logically follow Hadvar. His perspective introduces the complexity of the conflict, where neither side is purely virtuous. The choice also subtly affects your introduction to the world. With Ralof, you are a fellow victim of Imperial injustice. With Hadvar, you are an unfortunate civilian caught in a rebel's war. This initial lens can color how you perceive future interactions in holds like Windhelm and Solitude. It is the first step in defining your Dragonborn's political conscience and moral compass within the fractured world of Skyrim.

Chapter 5: The Long-Term View - Impact on the Civil War

A common misconception is that this choice locks you into a side for the Civil War questline. It does not. Regardless of whom you follow in Helgen, you are free to join either the Imperial Legion or the Stormcloaks later in the game by speaking to the relevant officers in Solitude or Windhelm. The Helgen decision is a narrative introduction, not a binding contract. Its long-term impact is therefore more thematic than mechanical. It provides context and personal connection. If you later join the Stormcloaks after escaping with Hadvar, it can feel like a redemption arc or a change of heart based on your travels. If you join the Imperials after escaping with Ralof, it might represent a realization that his cause is flawed. The choice seeds your understanding, making the eventual decision to commit to a side more informed and personally significant. It is the prologue to the Civil War saga, establishing the stakes and the human faces on both sides of the conflict.

Conclusion: A Choice That Defines Your Dragonborn

The question of whether to go with Hadvar or Ralof is a masterful piece of introductory game design. It presents a meaningful decision with layered consequences—practical, narrative, and role-playing. While the tangible gameplay effects are limited to the earliest hours, the psychological and thematic imprint lasts far longer. It forces the player to engage with the central conflict of Skyrim from moment one, transforming a tutorial escape into a statement of intent. There is no objectively superior choice; there is only the choice that fits the hero you wish to become. Will you be the pragmatist who sees the bigger picture with Hadvar, or the idealist who burns for freedom with Ralof? In Helgen's flames, your Dragonborn's story finds its first, defining spark. The path you take is less about who guides you out of a cave and more about whose version of Skyrim you choose to hear first, setting the stage for a legend uniquely your own.

Feature: U.S. homebuilders feel tariffs pain as costs keep rising
EPC summit highlights divisions over Ukraine's EU membership
U.S. tariff-related uncertainty to reduce Italy's GDP growth, employment: gov't entities
Sofia conference discusses Bulgaria's role in EU rearmament
Interview: BRICS mechanism boosts global governance reform, British scholar says