Xbox One vs. Xbox One S: A Definitive Comparison
Table of Contents
Introduction
The Core Distinction: A Generational Leap Within a Generation
Design and Form Factor: A Visual and Physical Transformation
Performance and Visual Fidelity: Beyond Resolution
4K Media and HDR: Transforming the Home Entertainment Experience
Storage and Value: Assessing the Practical Considerations
The Verdict: Which Console is Truly "Better"?
The question "Is Xbox One better than Xbox One S?" is a common one for gamers navigating the Xbox ecosystem. While the naming suggests a minor iteration, the Xbox One S represents a significant mid-generation refinement that addresses numerous shortcomings of the original model. To declare one definitively "better" requires a nuanced examination of their differences in design, performance, media capabilities, and overall value. This analysis will demonstrate that for the vast majority of users, the Xbox One S is the superior choice, effectively rendering the original Xbox One obsolete for new buyers.
The fundamental distinction lies in the Xbox One S being a comprehensive hardware revision, not merely a cosmetic update. Microsoft engineered the Xbox One S to be a more efficient and capable device. The most notable technical improvement is the relocation of the internal power supply. The original Xbox One's bulky external power brick is eliminated in the S model, integrating the power supply within a much sleeker chassis. This single change dramatically improves the user experience by reducing cable clutter and simplifying setup. Furthermore, the Xbox One S supports stand vertical orientation, a flexibility the original console lacks. These refinements signal a console designed for the modern entertainment center, prioritizing aesthetics and practicality.
Regarding pure gaming performance, the difference, while present, is subtle rather than revolutionary. Both consoles run the same library of games at identical target frame rates and resolutions. The Xbox One S does not target native 4K gaming. However, it possesses a modest GPU clock speed increase, which is often utilized for more stable dynamic resolution scaling in certain titles. This means that in games where the original Xbox One might drop resolution to maintain performance, the Xbox One S can maintain a slightly higher pixel count, resulting in a marginally sharper and more consistent image. A more universal performance gain is in loading times, thanks to the S model's move to faster DDR3 RAM and more efficient memory bandwidth management. While you will not see double the frame rates, the overall experience on the Xbox One S feels more polished and technically sound.
Where the Xbox One S establishes a clear and undeniable advantage is in its home media capabilities. This is the console's flagship feature upgrade. The Xbox One S includes a built-in Ultra HD Blu-ray drive, allowing it to play physical 4K movies. The original Xbox One lacks this capability entirely. Coupled with this is full support for High Dynamic Range (HDR) for both gaming and video, through standards like HDR10. HDR expands the range of color and contrast, delivering brighter highlights, deeper blacks, and a more vibrant, realistic image. For anyone with a 4K HDR television, the Xbox One S transforms into a compelling media hub. Streaming apps like Netflix and Amazon Prime Video also benefit, providing 4K HDR content that the original console cannot match. This media supremacy is a primary reason the Xbox One S is considered a generational leap in the living room.
Practical considerations further tilt the balance. The Xbox One S was launched with a starting storage capacity of 500GB, later offering 1TB and 2TB models, compared to the original's standard 500GB. Given the increasing size of game installations, larger default storage is a tangible benefit. The revised Xbox Wireless Controller shipped with the S model also introduced subtle but meaningful improvements, including textured grips, an extended range, and Bluetooth support for connecting to Windows PCs and mobile devices without a dedicated wireless adapter. From a value perspective, even at launch, the Xbox One S typically offered more features at a price point similar to or lower than the aging original model. It presented a significantly better value proposition, bundling enhanced hardware, media features, and a refined controller.
In conclusion, the answer to whether the Xbox One is better than the Xbox One S is decisively negative. The Xbox One S is objectively the better console in nearly every measurable aspect. It is smaller, quieter, more energy-efficient, and features a vastly superior media portfolio with 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray and HDR support. Its gaming performance, while not transformative, offers welcome stability improvements. The only scenario where the original Xbox One might be considered is an extreme budget constraint, where it is available for a significantly lower used price, and the user has no current or future intention of using a 4K HDR television. For every other user—from the casual gamer and movie enthusiast to the dedicated player seeking the best version of the Xbox One experience—the Xbox One S is the unequivocal choice. It represents the mature, refined vision of Microsoft's console, making the original model a relic of a first draft. The Xbox One S successfully fulfilled its role as a necessary and impactful revision, solidifying its place as the definitive version of the Xbox One family.
Egypt opens Grand Egyptian Museum, eyes tourism boom, economic liftIsrael agrees to necessary conditions to finalize 60-day ceasefire in Gaza: Trump
Gaza ceasefire right direction towards lasting peace: Egyptian president
U.S. birth rate still near historical low: CDC
Explainer: Is the new Ukraine "peace plan" a real deal for peace?
【contact us】
Version update
V1.98.705