infamous vs prototype

Table of Contents

Introduction: The Dawn of a Subgenre

Duality of Power: Morality Systems and Player Agency

The Anti-Hero Persona: Cole MacGrath vs. Alex Mercer

Urban Playgrounds: Navigating New Marais and Manhattan Zero

Spectacle of Destruction: Contrasting Combat Philosophies

Narrative Ambition: Personal Conspiracy vs. Existential Horror

Legacy and Influence: Defining the Superhero Power Fantasy

Conclusion: Two Sides of the Same Chaotic Coin

The late 2000s witnessed a fascinating phenomenon in the action-adventure genre: the nearly simultaneous emergence of two titles that redefined the concept of the superhuman power fantasy. inFAMOUS and Prototype, released within a month of each other in 2009, presented players with unprecedented levels of destructive capability set against sprawling urban landscapes. While superficially similar—both featuring protagonists with extraordinary abilities scaling cityscapes—they embarked on radically different philosophical and mechanical journeys. Their concurrent release sparked immediate comparison, framing a debate that endures: two distinct visions of empowerment, one bound by moral consequence, the other by amoral, visceral freedom.

A fundamental divergence lies in their approach to player choice and consequence. inFAMOUS is built upon a robust karma system that directly shapes the protagonist Cole MacGrath's abilities, appearance, and the world's reaction to him. Choosing heroic actions grants blue-hued "Good" powers focused on precision and non-lethal crowd control, while embracing infamy unlocks red "Evil" abilities that prioritize raw, explosive area damage. This system is woven into the narrative, with NPCs cheering or fleeing based on Cole's alignment, and story branches offering distinct endings. It frames power as a responsibility, asking the player to consciously define their version of Cole. Prototype, in stark contrast, offers no such moral binary. Alex Mercer is, by his nature, a predatory and vengeful entity. His powers, derived from consuming biomass and absorbing memories, are inherently violent. The player's agency lies not in choosing a moral path, but in the tactical and brutal application of a vast, gruesome arsenal. The freedom is absolute and amoral, concerned with efficacy, not ethics.

This dichotomy extends to the protagonists themselves. Cole MacGrath begins as an everyman courier, granted electrical powers after a catastrophic explosion devastates Empire City. His journey, whether towards heroism or tyranny, is one of transformation and grappling with a destiny thrust upon him. Players witness his internal conflict and the physical toll of his powers, creating a thread of relatability. Alex Mercer, however, is an amnesiac shapeshifting bioweapon from the outset. He is less a traditional character and more a force of nature—an angry, confused, and supremely powerful entity seeking answers and revenge. His lack of conventional morality makes him a vessel for pure, unchecked player id. Where Cole's story is about becoming something, Alex's is about uncovering what he is, with the revelation being that he is the very catastrophe he is investigating.

The cities of New Marais and Manhattan Zero serve as more than backdrops; they are reactive playgrounds designed for different styles of engagement. New Marais, with its distinct districts and verticality, is tailored for Cole's parkour and electrical grid-based traversal. Its design often presents clear pathways for grinding on power lines or scaling buildings, encouraging fluid, circuit-like movement. The city feels like a part of Cole's toolkit. Prototype's rendition of Manhattan, infected by the Blacklight virus, is a denser, more chaotic warzone. Alex's movement is exponentially more explosive—sprinting up skyscrapers, gliding for miles, and air-dashing with immense force. The city is a landscape to be dominated and consumed, its rooftops highways and its streets hunting grounds. The military and infected enemies create a constant, chaotic battle that makes the environment feel perpetually hostile.

Combat further highlights their contrasting philosophies. Cole's electrical powers, even in their evil incarnations, maintain a certain comic-book elegance—targeted lightning bolts, ionic vortexes, and precision sniper shots. Strategy often involves managing a power meter and using the environment. Alex Mercer's combat is visceral, biological, and brutally intimate. His shapeshifting arms morph into colossal claws, devastating hammers, and whip-like tendrils. The iconic "Devastator" moves are area-of-effect eruptions of biomass. Most telling is the "Consume" ability, a stealth-takedown that highlights the core predatory fantasy. Combat in Prototype is about overwhelming force and grotesque spectacle, while inFAMOUS blends power with a degree of tactical finesse.

Narratively, both games employ conspiracy tropes but to different ends. inFAMOUS tells a personal story of betrayal, sacrifice, and legacy, framed by a present-day Cole narrating past events to a future listener. Its conspiracies are human-scale, involving corporations, militias, and other conduits. Prototype plunges into a sci-fi horror narrative of genetic manipulation, runaway bioweapons, and government cover-ups. Alex's ability to "consume" individuals and absorb their memories and form drives a non-linear, puzzle-box narrative where the player pieces together the truth alongside him. The tone is paranoid and apocalyptic, whereas inFAMOUS, even at its darkest, retains a strand of comic-book heroism or anti-heroism.

The legacy of these two titles is deeply interwoven. They proved the commercial viability of open-world superhero games outside established comic book licenses. inFAMOUS demonstrated how moral choice could be meaningfully integrated into gameplay mechanics and narrative, influencing later titles that sought to make player decisions impactful. Its success led to a direct sequel and the well-received inFAMOUS: Second Son. Prototype carved out a niche for a specific kind of power fantasy—one of absolute, cathartic, and morally unburdened destruction. Its influence is felt in games that prioritize sheer, joyful physicality and environmental chaos over narrative consequence. Together, they represent the two poles of the power fantasy spectrum: the burden of great power and the thrill of absolute freedom.

Ultimately, the inFAMOUS versus Prototype debate is not about determining a superior game, but about recognizing two masterful yet opposing executions of a core fantasy. inFAMOUS offers a journey of identity and choice, where power is a catalyst for character definition. Prototype provides an outlet for primal, unrestrained id, where power is a tool for domination and survival. One is a story about a man struggling with becoming a god; the other is about a god struggling to remember he was ever a man. They remain iconic precisely because they answered the same question—"What if you could have incredible superpowers in an open world?"—with such brilliantly different, definitive, and unforgettable voices.

S. Korean acting president, prime minister Han resigns
New round of direct talks between Russia, Ukraine to focus on draft memos
Israeli negotiators to leave Monday for Gaza ceasefire talks in Egypt: Netanyahu
World will no longer wait for absent U.S.
U.S. Senator from California forcibly removed from press conference held by Homeland Security Secretary