elden ring ray tracing comparison

Elden Ring: A Ray Tracing Comparison - Illuminating The Lands Between

Table of Contents

Introduction: The Promise of Enhanced Realism

The Technical Foundation: Ray Tracing Modes Explained

Visual Analysis: Shadows, Reflections, and Ambient Occlusion

Performance Impact: Frame Rate Trade-offs and Hardware Demands

Artistic Cohesion: Does Ray Tracing Enhance the Vision?

The Verdict: Is It Worth The Performance Cost?

Conclusion: A Faint, Yet Noticeable Glimmer

Introduction: The Promise of Enhanced Realism

FromSoftware's Elden Ring captivated players with its vast, painterly world and intricate environmental storytelling. Upon its initial release, the game's visual presentation relied on traditional rasterization techniques, crafting its haunting beauty through pre-baked lighting, screen-space reflections, and shadow maps. The subsequent introduction of ray tracing promised a transformative leap in visual fidelity, aiming to ground the fantastical landscapes of the Lands Between in a new layer of physical realism. This comparison delves into the tangible differences ray tracing brings to Elden Ring, scrutinizing its implementation, its impact on performance, and ultimately, whether it substantively alters the experience or remains a subtle enhancement for high-end hardware.

The Technical Foundation: Ray Tracing Modes Explained

Elden Ring's ray tracing update is not a single, all-encompassing preset. Instead, it offers two primary modes: Ray Tracing Quality and Ray Tracing Performance. Both modes implement a specific suite of ray-traced effects. The cornerstone is ray-traced shadows. This replaces the standard cascade shadow maps with dynamically calculated shadows that exhibit accurate penumbrae, meaning soft edges that naturally blur over distance. Ray-traced ambient occlusion is also employed, calculating how exposed surfaces are to ambient light, resulting in more grounded and realistic contact shadows in crevices, under foliage, and where objects meet. Notably absent are ray-traced global illumination, which would dynamically bounce colored light, and comprehensive ray-traced reflections. The reflections present are limited and selective, primarily affecting certain indoor and water surfaces, while most other reflective surfaces continue to use screen-space techniques.

Visual Analysis: Shadows, Reflections, and Ambient Occlusion

The most immediately noticeable improvement lies in shadow quality. In dense forests like Limgrave's Mistwood, ray-traced shadows eliminate the pixelated, crawling artifacts common in shadow maps. Individual leaves and branches cast distinct, softly blended shadows, creating a canopy of light that feels organic and dynamic. The extended draw distance for these shadows means structures and trees cast long, consistent shadows at sunset, enhancing the world's scale. The ambient occlusion subtly but effectively deepens scenes. The intricate stonework of Stormveil Castle or the roots of the Erdtree gain volume and definition, with cracks and recesses appearing more pronounced and realistic.

However, the implementation has limitations. The much-anticipated reflections are a mixed bag. While puddles in catacombs or the still water in certain caves gain accurate, ray-traced reflections, large bodies of water and most glossy surfaces do not. The visual impact is therefore situational. Furthermore, the ray-traced lighting does not interact with all light sources uniformly, and in some interior spaces, the difference can be remarkably subtle, leading to questions about the cost versus benefit in those specific environments.

Performance Impact: Frame Rate Trade-offs and Hardware Demands

Ray tracing in Elden Ring carries a significant performance penalty, a critical factor given the game's real-time combat demands. Enabling Ray Tracing Quality mode can result in a 30-40% reduction in frame rates on even high-end GPUs like the NVIDIA RTX 4080 or AMD RX 7900 XTX. The Performance mode mitigates this somewhat, but the hit remains substantial. This often forces a difficult choice: targeting a stable 60 frames per second with ray tracing may require upscaling technology like DLSS or FSR and lowering other settings, while high-refresh-rate gameplay becomes exceedingly demanding.

The performance cost highlights that Elden Ring's engine, while masterful in art direction, was not originally built with real-time ray tracing as a core pillar. The penalty feels steeper than in some other titles with more holistic implementations, making it a feature squarely aimed at users with the latest graphics hardware who prioritize visual immersion over maximum frame rates.

Artistic Cohesion: Does Ray Tracing Enhance the Vision?

This is the most subjective and crucial question. FromSoftware's worlds are renowned for their deliberate, artistic lighting—a tool used to guide the player, set mood, and hide threats. Ray tracing, by its physically accurate nature, can sometimes work against this curated artistry. However, in Elden Ring, the effect generally complements the vision. The enhanced shadows in the atmospheric swamps of Liurnia or the haunting depths of Caelid add to the dread and immersion. The more realistic occlusion makes environments feel less like constructed levels and more like tangible spaces.

Yet, it does not revolutionize the art style. The game's iconic golden hue, its fantastical skyboxes, and its stark contrasts are products of artistic design, not physical simulation. Ray tracing refines the foundation without altering the painting on top. For some players, this subtle grounding of the world is invaluable. For others, the distinctive, sometimes surreal lighting of the original rasterized version remains the definitive artistic statement.

The Verdict: Is It Worth The Performance Cost?

The value of Elden Ring's ray tracing is inherently tied to the player's priorities and hardware. For a first playthrough, especially on mid-range systems, the performance cost is difficult to justify. The core aesthetic and gameplay experience are fully intact without it. For veterans on powerful PCs embarking on a new journey, ray tracing offers a compelling reason to revisit the Lands Between with a fresh, more immersive perspective. The enhanced shadows and ambient occlusion provide a consistent, if subtle, upgrade to environmental realism.

It is not a transformative, must-have feature like it can be in games built from the ground up with ray tracing. Instead, it is a premium enhancement—a layer of polish that makes an already beautiful world feel more physically cohesive and grounded. The decision to enable it is a direct trade-off: sacrificing smoothness and responsiveness for increased visual immersion in exploration and slower-paced moments.

Conclusion: A Faint, Yet Noticeable Glimmer

The Elden Ring ray tracing comparison reveals an implementation that is effective within a specific scope. It delivers markedly improved shadows and more convincing ambient occlusion, which steadily enhances environmental believability. However, its limited reflection support and substantial performance impact prevent it from being a universally recommended setting. It succeeds not by reinventing the game's visuals but by subtly reinforcing them with a layer of physical lighting accuracy. For those with the hardware to spare, it allows the Lands Between to shine—or more accurately, to shadow—in a new, more realistic light. For everyone else, the original, masterfully crafted rasterized vision loses none of its power and remains the most practical way to experience this monumental title. The ray tracing, in the end, is a faint but noticeable glimmer on an already brilliant masterpiece.

U.S., Ukraine, Europe meet in Switzerland to discuss Ukraine peace plan
India's top court modifies directive regarding removal of stray dogs from Delhi, outskirts
Top DPRK leader meets visiting senior Russian official
Trump says U.S. to hold talks with Iran next week
U.S. judge rules Trump's cuts to NIH funding illegal